About the song
“Make Believe It’s Your First Time” by The Carpenters is a beautifully crafted ballad that showcases Karen Carpenter’s unparalleled vocal delivery, paired with the duo’s characteristic lush arrangements. Released in 1983 as part of their posthumous album Voice of the Heart, this song stands as a poignant reminder of the enduring emotional depth and artistry of The Carpenters. It also highlights Karen’s ability to convey deep emotion, making every word resonate with listeners.
Background and Release
The song was included in Voice of the Heart, an album released shortly after Karen Carpenter’s untimely passing in February 1983. This album features tracks that were recorded during the later years of The Carpenters’ career and carefully curated by her brother and collaborator, Richard Carpenter. Among these, “Make Believe It’s Your First Time” stands out for its simplicity and heartfelt sentiment.
Interestingly, the song was first recorded by Karen Carpenter in 1979 during the sessions for her solo album, but the version on Voice of the Heart features her brother’s arrangement and the classic Carpenters’ style. The contrast between these versions highlights the versatility of Karen’s voice and the nuanced production approach of Richard.
Meaning and Emotional Impact
At its core, “Make Believe It’s Your First Time” is a tender and reflective love song. The lyrics urge a partner to rekindle the spark of a relationship, to embrace love as if it were fresh and new. Lines like “Let’s pretend that it’s never happened before, make believe it’s your first time, and I’ll be yours” capture the yearning for intimacy and renewal in a relationship. This universal theme of rediscovering love adds a timeless quality to the song.
Karen’s vocal performance elevates the song to another level. Her delivery is intimate and delicate, as though she is sharing a deeply personal story. This emotional vulnerability, combined with the soft piano accompaniment and gentle orchestration, creates an atmosphere of bittersweet beauty. It’s a song that can evoke nostalgia, hope, and a sense of longing in equal measure.
Cultural and Emotional Legacy
Though “Make Believe It’s Your First Time” was not one of The Carpenters’ biggest commercial hits, it has become a fan favorite and a testament to the duo’s ability to create music that touches the soul. The song’s release as part of Voice of the Heart also marked a poignant moment in The Carpenters’ history. It was part of a collection of songs that celebrated Karen’s legacy, ensuring that her voice continued to resonate with fans even after her passing.
The song also holds a unique place in the Carpenters’ catalog as a piece that reflects both the joys and the sorrows of love. For many listeners, it serves as a reminder of Karen’s extraordinary ability to channel emotion through her voice, making each song feel deeply personal. It’s no surprise that fans often describe her performances as unmatched in their sincerity and authenticity.
Conclusion
“Make Believe It’s Your First Time” is more than just a love song—it’s a reflection of The Carpenters’ artistry and the enduring appeal of Karen Carpenter’s voice. Released in 1983 as part of the album Voice of the Heart, the track combines heartfelt lyrics, gentle instrumentation, and Karen’s unmatched vocal delivery to create a song that continues to touch hearts. Its themes of rediscovery and emotional intimacy resonate universally, making it a timeless piece of music. For fans of The Carpenters, it serves as a poignant reminder of Karen’s extraordinary talent and the legacy she left behind.
Video
Lyrics
We’ve tried our handAt love beforeWe’ve been around the game enoughTo know the score’But then is thenAnd now is nowAnd now is all that matters anyhowMake believe it’s your first timeLeave your sadness behindMake believe it’s your first timeAnd I’ll make believe it’s mineThe door is closedIt’s you and meWe’ll take our time with loveThe way it oughta beThis moment’s oursTonight’s the nightAnd if we fall in loveWell, that’s alrightMake believe it’s your first timeLeave your sadness behindMake believe it’s your first timeAnd I’ll make believe it’s mineSo close your eyesAnd hold me closeAnd let our hearts pretendThat love is ours to share tonightAnd it might never endMake believe it’s your first timeLeave your sadness behindMake believe it’s your first timeAnd I’ll make believe it’s mine