The Four Tops – If I Were A Carpenter

About the song

Released in 1968 as part of The Four Tops’ album Yesterday’s Dreams, “If I Were a Carpenter” showcases the legendary Motown group’s ability to transform a folk song into a deeply soulful, emotionally charged performance. Originally written and recorded by Tim Hardin in 1966, the song has been covered by numerous artists, but The Four Tops brought a uniquely passionate, Motown-infused energy to it, making their version stand out as one of the most powerful interpretations.

A Soulful Take on a Timeless Question

At its heart, “If I Were a Carpenter” is a poignant love song that questions the value of love versus social status. The lyrics present a hypothetical scenario: If I were a simple working man, would you still love me? It’s a universal theme—asking whether love is based on true emotional connection or material wealth. This question resonated deeply during the 1960s, a decade marked by social change, class struggles, and a rejection of traditional norms.

While Hardin’s original version was gentle and introspective, The Four Tops, led by the powerful vocals of Levi Stubbs, turned it into something far more dramatic and urgent. The sweeping orchestration, dynamic instrumentation, and impassioned delivery elevate the song beyond folk introspection into a heartfelt soul ballad, filled with raw emotion and intensity.

Motown Magic: The Four Tops’ Distinctive Style

What sets The Four Tops’ version apart is Levi Stubbs’ incredible vocal performance. Unlike the subdued, folk-style delivery of earlier renditions, Stubbs sings with an aching sincerity, as if pleading for an answer. His gritty, emotionally charged voice brings out the underlying desperation and vulnerability in the lyrics, making the song feel more immediate and deeply personal.

Backing him are Duke Fakir, Renaldo “Obie” Benson, and Lawrence Payton, whose harmonies provide the rich, full-bodied sound that The Four Tops were famous for. The Motown production, characterized by lush strings, a steady rhythm, and soaring melodies, adds depth and grandeur, transforming the song from a quiet folk ballad into a soulful masterpiece.

A Song That Bridges Genres and Generations

Originally rooted in folk music, “If I Were a Carpenter” proved to be a song that transcended genres, with versions by Bobby Darin, Johnny Cash & June Carter, and Robert Plant all adding different textures to its narrative. However, The Four Tops’ version stands as one of the most unique, bringing Motown soul into the mix and giving the song a new life and audience.

During the late 1960s, when Motown was at the peak of its influence, the label wasn’t just producing danceable pop hits—it was also crafting deeply emotional, socially aware music. The Four Tops were known for their passionate, storytelling-driven songs, and “If I Were a Carpenter” fit perfectly into their repertoire, aligning with themes of love, loyalty, and devotion that resonated with listeners across different backgrounds.

Legacy and Lasting Impact

Although not as commercially dominant as some of their biggest hits like “Reach Out I’ll Be There” or “I Can’t Help Myself (Sugar Pie, Honey Bunch)”, “If I Were a Carpenter” remains a shining example of The Four Tops’ ability to take an existing song and completely redefine it. Their version gave the song new emotional weight, demonstrating Motown’s unique ability to blend storytelling with deep, expressive performances.

Decades later, this song still holds a powerful emotional charge, speaking to the timeless nature of love and devotion. Whether heard as a folk ballad, a country duet, or a soul anthem, “If I Were a Carpenter” continues to move audiences, and The Four Tops’ rendition remains one of the most heartfelt and memorable versions ever recorded.

Video

Lyrics

If I were a carpenter
And you were a lady
Now, would you marry me anyway (would you marry me anyway?)
Would you have my baby? (Would you have my baby?)

If I take on a tinker’s trade
Would you still find me
Oh, carrying the pots I made (carrying the pots I made)
Close up behind me? (Following behind me)

Save my love through loneliness
Save my love for sorrow
‘Cause I have given you my onliness
Give me part of your tomorrow

If I worked my hands in wood (yes I would, babe, to keep your love, babe)
Would you still love me?
Now answer me babe, “Yes, I would (yes I would, babe, to keep your love, babe)
Place you high above me”

If I were a miller
At a mill wheel grinding
Now, would you miss your color box (would you miss your color box?)
Your soft shoes are shining (and your soft shoe shining?)

If I were a carpenter
And you were a lady
Would you marry me anyway (would you marry me anyway?)
Would you have my baby? (Would you have my baby?)
If I were a carpenter
And you were a lady
Would you marry anyway
Would you have my baby?